Gold News

Stock Market Peaks, Gold ATM Returns: Cue Tickertape

Signs of a top in everything, even gold...

REMEMBER when today's record-breaking uptrend in stocks and shares was the "least loved bull market" in history? asks Adrian Ash at BullionVault, talking to Weekly Update subscribers back on Monday, before this week's market trouble got started.

That's what many analysts, traders and pundits called the upturn in US equities starting at the depths of the global financial crisis...

...way back in March 2009.

While the stock market bounced and moved sharply higher after the Lehman's crash, most people worried that the crisis was about to crush equities once more, and they kept doubting that the new bull market could keep running.

But "Wall Street is no longer the bastion of free and open markets," said one gloomster of the Least Loved Bull Market a few years later.

"Instead, market prices are determined by political appointees, called central bankers, who pull the monetary levers behind the scenes."

Maybe so. The latest flood of cheap and free money has coincided with the US stock market reaching its most expensive since the peak of the DotCom Bubble in terms of share prices versus the earnings actually being made by those companies.

The rest of the world is catching up. It hasn't been this pricey since the DotCom Bubble crashed either.

Forward price/earning ratios for world stock markets. Source:

But who needs earnings anyway?

Well over a third of US-listed corporations currently make less than they spend every year.

A record 80% of 2020's new stock-market listings came from companies making a loss.

And with investors no longer bothering to look for actual profits in the companies they buy, the S&P500 index of US corporations has now risen 6 times over since the 2009 low...

...surging past its previous all-time peaks, even amid the Covid pandemic and lockdowns...

...and setting a new all-time high on 36 of the 126 trading days so far this year.

Seven of them came in the last 7 working days.

So today's 4th of July holiday looks like a well deserved rest for the bulls.

It also comes against a backdrop of unbridled bullishness.

"Investors don't see end to record-breaking stock market rally just yet," says Reuters.

"Vaccination is accelerating globally, major central banks remain extremely accommodative, fiscal support is still present and earnings continue to recover," says one strategist.

"In such an environment, it is difficult to imagine a very negative scenario for equities."

Hard to disagree. Not even the deflationary shock of 2020 could derail this bull market.

Maybe it's because reality...and real stuff...simply matters much less in our tech-driven world than it used to.

Proportion of 'intangible' equity in S&P500 index. Source: Visual Capitalist

"50 years ago," notes a pundit on Twitter, "a company's value was overwhelmingly derived from its physical capital...

"...the assembly lines & buildings it owned, and the products it made.

"Today's firms are built on intangible capital. It accounts for as much as 90% of the S&P500's total assets, up from just 17% in 1975."

"Is that caused in part by tax-driven accounting sleight-of-hand?" someone else asks.

"Mostly it is just that today's firms are built on intangible capital," comes the answer, "assets in the form of software algorithms, brand, customer data, business plans, engineering specifications, product formulas & organisational capital..

"Software ate the world & created great wealth."

Again, hard to disagree. But old habits die hard, even here at software and fintech pioneers BullionVault (where real stuff really does matter of course).

Oh sure, detailed analysis might say there's nothing to worry about in today's fresh all-time stock market highs.

But we still find the world littered with signs and signals that walk, talk and dance just like a big ugly stock-market top...

...from cheerleaders punting "AMC to the moon!" at Spring Break pool parties... trading app Robinhood preparing to float itself on the stock market...

...while the big-brain bosses of America's hottest stocks fall over each other to be the first billionaire in space...

...leaving financial regulators looking very earth-bound in trying to police the whole thing.

No wonder the UK's Financial Conduct Authority wants to do away with boring old rules as it tries to attract more hot stocks to float here in London.

No wonder US regulators at the SEC are throwing both cheerleaders and Robinhood's famous confetti drops into their new consumer-advice adverts.

"I had no idea investing regularly could add up this much," says an actor in one SEC advert, missing yet mocking the meme-stock mania.

"I had no idea it was that easy to diversify my portfolio," says another.

Big deal. Who needs to diversify when stocks and shares just keep rising?

In fact, the wider Wilshire 5000 index of US corporations has now risen so high it has got back to level pegging with gold bullion.

Both have now risen around 50 times from their value 50 years ago.

Gold priced in Dollars vs. Wilshire 5000 stock-market index. Source: St.Louis Fed

So what about our own little corner of the market?

Central-bank money printing should, at first glance, be just as good for bullion as it is for the stock market.

So the interest-rate rises and QE tapering now being discussed thanks to 2021's jump to 3-decade highs for inflation would very likely hit gold and silver prices just as badly as the stock market too.

And if you want a 'top of the gold market' signal to go with the stock-market top, how about the return of the much-missed gold ATM...?

"Well-heeled Munich residents can now get their gold supplies from a vending machine at Promenadeplatz," says German newspaper Süddeutsche Zeitung.

Pulling small gold bars out of cash-point first made headlines back at the top of gold's first 21st Century bull market in 2009-2011.

Sucked in by its PR success, several operators tried to make this "Gold To Go" idea work over the following few years as well, but again without success.

Now it's back and winning headlines all over again.

Time to sell?

Gold is often promoted as the ultimate inflation defence. And across the last half-century of free-floating currencies and precious metals, it has indeed tended to rise faster when the cost of living moved sharply higher than when inflation was quiet.

Most dramatically it surged during the inflationary 1970s...

...rising 9-fold in real inflation-adjusted terms for US savers even as the cost of living doubled across that decade.

But gold has also proven to be a very reliable stock market hedge as well...

...repeatedly gaining value when the equity market fell and kept falling.

Since the early 1970s in fact, and looking at 5-year returns, gold priced in the Dollar has risen 98.0% of the time that the S&P500 index has fallen from a half-decade before.

No, past performance is no guarantee of future returns. But a 98% strike rate across 5 decades of data is worth a look. And if you can't (or won't) guess where the stock market might be trading in 2026, then owning a little more (or less) gold as a hedge looks to me like a very sensible thing to consider.

No, spreading your risk is not exciting, and it almost certainly means you will miss out on making the maximum possible gains compared with putting 100% of your eggs into the one basket which then proves the most profitable.

But how can you guess which basket that will be?

We diversify because, while we cannot know the future, we know we will want to avoid having had our savings wiped out before we get there.

Cue tickertape and cheerleaders.


Adrian Ash

Adrian Ash, BullionVault Gold News

Adrian Ash is director of research at BullionVault, the world-leading physical gold, silver and platinum market for private investors online. Formerly head of editorial at London's top publisher of private-investment advice, he was City correspondent for The Daily Reckoning from 2003 to 2008, and he has now been researching and writing daily analysis of precious metals and the wider financial markets for over 20 years. A frequent guest on BBC radio and television, Adrian is regularly quoted by the Financial Times, MarketWatch and many other respected news outlets, and his views from inside the bullion market have been sought by the Economist magazine, CNBC, Bloomberg, Germany's Handelsblatt and FAZ, plus Italy's Il Sole 24 Ore.

See the full archive of Adrian Ash articles on GoldNews.

Please Note: All articles published here are to inform your thinking, not lead it. Only you can decide the best place for your money, and any decision you make will put your money at risk. Information or data included here may have already been overtaken by events – and must be verified elsewhere – should you choose to act on it. Please review our Terms & Conditions for accessing Gold News.

Follow Us

Facebook Youtube Twitter LinkedIn



Market Fundamentals