Gold News

The Parabolic Yield Curve

Just what is going on with the US Treasury bond market...?

depends upon listening properly, writes Gary Dorsch of Global Money Trends.

Of ten people who listen to the same speech or story, each person may well understand it differently – and perhaps only one of them will understand it correctly.

How then should traders interpret the shape of the US Treasury's yield curve, which has gone parabolic this spring, steepening to its highest level since 2004? It's not only a US phenomenon, with long-term government bonds now offering sharply higher interest than short-term bonds in Europe and the UK. In Australia, the Treasury yield curve is at its steepest in history.

Not surprisingly, Federal Reserve officials were quick to provide a few explanations. "In recent weeks, yields on longer-term Treasury securities and fixed-rate mortgages have risen," said Fed chief Ben "Bubbles" Bernanke on June 3rd. "These increases reflect concerns about large federal deficits, but also greater optimism about the economic outlook, a reversal of flight-to-quality flows, and technical factors related to the hedging of mortgage holdings," he explained.

As the massive shockwaves to the financial markets from Lehman Brother's collapse in September have subsided, and the once frozen corporate bond market has thawed-out, the panic that caused Treasury-bill rates to briefly fall below zero percent for the first time is a fading memory. Fears of another "Great Depression" of the 1930s have been replaced with cautious optimism over the arrival of "green-shoots" or signs that the global economy is stabilizing from its free-fall.

Alongside the swift recovery of the global stock markets, the US Treasury yield curve has gone parabolic, and the Fed's propaganda artists are wringing their hands of any culpability. "I personally don't believe the rise in long-term bond yields is due to inflation fears," said Dallas Fed chief Richard Fisher on June 2nd. Rather, "the yield curve's steepening appears to reflect an improvement in the economic outlook, combined with the Treasury's huge borrowing needs," he said.

Typically the Treasury yield curve steepens when long-term yields are rising faster than shorter-term rates, and the majority of traders are anticipating an economic recovery, to be followed by a tightening of monetary policy. Conversely, the rare appearance of an "inverted yield curve" (where short-term rates are above longer-term yields) has typically materialized near the end of a tightening cycle, and in many cases, telegraphs an economic recession within 12-to-18-months.

The steepening of the US Treasury yield curve is one of the great mysteries in the marketplace today. The US Treasury's 10-year note is yielding about 255-basis points above the 2-year yield, which is somewhat of an anomaly. Such a wide spread would normally be associated with expectations of a V-shaped recovery for the US economy. Moreover, the Fed would typically send hints to the markets that it's ready to start draining excess liquidity from the money markets, in order to keep inflationary pressures in check.

But on May 24th, Fed deputy Donald Kohn tried to calm jittery Treasury bond investors, arguing that expectations of a V-shaped recovery are far-fetched.

"The US-economy is only now beginning to show signs that it might be stabilizing, and the upturn, when it begins, is likely to be gradual amid the balance sheet repair of financial intermediaries and households. As a consequence, it probably will be some time before the Fed begins to raise its target for the federal funds rate."

However, Kohn's remarks failed to stop the bleeding in the Treasury bond market, and yields jumped to their highest levels in seven-months. The Fed's experiment with nuclear "Quantitative Easing" (QE) is backfiring. The borrowing costs that Bernanke & Company aim to drive lower, are instead, moving higher, despite the Fed's stated commitment to buy $300-billion of long-term Treasury notes through August, with US-dollars rolling off its electronic printing press.

So far, the Fed has bought $150-billion of Treasury debt under the QE framework, but that amount pales in comparison to the $2-trillion supply of new debt that is swamping the credit market this year.

This week, the Treasury has been auctioning $35 billion in three-year notes, $19bn in 10-year notes, and $11bn in 30-year bonds. Given the massive deluge of new supply, the Fed has been unable to manhandle the Treasury market. Its original goal of enforcing a lid on the benchmark 10-year yield at 3.00% has been blown to smithereens.

The Fed tried to follow the blueprints of the Bank of Japan (BoJ), which uses strong-arm tactics in the $8.5-trillion Tokyo bond market, through skillful manipulation and jawboning exercises. Japan's 10-year bond (JGB) yield has been locked within a tight range between 1.15% and 2.00% for the past ten-years, even through the inflation boom cycle, that carried crude oil to $145 per barrel last year.

Now that the Fed is halfway through its money printing binge, it may soon have to decide whether to up the ante, by ramping-up its Treasury debt purchases to as much as $1-trillion. But of course, the big risk with massive QE overdoses is that the gambit could end-up crushing the value of the US-dollar and intensify inflation fears that are festering in the bond market, pushing yields higher.

What Fed officials must be very worried about privately (but refuse to say publicly) is that "nuclear-QE" could lead to hyper-inflation and foreign flight from American bonds.

Less than one-week after the Fed stunned the markets, by saying it would monetize $300bn of Treasury debt and $800bn of mortgage bonds, China's central bank proposed replacing the US Dollar as the international reserve currency – a clear sign that Beijing, the largest holder of $1.5 trillion in US Dollar bonds, is very worried about the inflationary risk of the Fed's money printing operations.

Ahead of the Group-of-20 summit in London on April 2nd, the Kremlin also put forward a plan for a supra-national currency to replace the US Dollar. "We have received proposals from our colleagues in China, detailed proposals," said Russian President Dmitry Medvedev's top economic adviser Arkady Dvorkovich.

"Our positions are very similar. We have similar positions on the development of the international financial architecture," he said. Still, Moscow cautioned that while discussions are underway, the emergence of the new global currency won't happen overnight.

On May 27th, Dallas Fed chief Fisher told the Wall Street Journal that "officials of the Chinese government grilled me about whether or not we are going to monetize the actions of our legislature. I must have been asked about that a hundred times in China. I was asked at every single meeting about our purchases of Treasuries. That seemed to be the principal preoccupation of those that were invested with their surpluses mostly in the United States," he warned.

Indeed, Brazilian president Mr Lula da Silva and Hu Jintao, China's president, are already discussing a plan to bypass the US Dollar with the Chinese Yuan and the Brazilian Real in direct trade between the two emerging economic giants. Brazil and Argentina have signed an agreement under which importers and exporters in the two countries can receive payments in Pesos and Reals directly, without the need of using the US Dollar as an intermediary of exchange.

While speculators in the global stock markets see the "green-shoots" of economic recovery, Treasury bond vigilantes see a tsunami of US dollars printed by Fed chief Ben "Bubbles" Bernanke, sparking a new wave of inflation worldwide.

The US Dollar is tumbling in unison with a sliding T-bond market – an ominous sign. Conversely, the sharp slide of the US Dollar is boosting the Dow Jones Commodity Index, up 25% since early March, while lifting crude oil above $70 per barrel.

The global financial crisis has hastened the day when the non-Western economies, such as Brazil, China, India, Korea, and Russia, will produce more than half of the world's output, for the first time since the middle of the nineteenth century. By 2012, the Western industrialized nations will account for just 45% of the world economy, if current trends remain intact. China will overtake Japan to become the world's second largest economy this year in Dollar terms. And one of the knock-on effects of China and India's resiliency is sharp rebounds in crude oil and commodity prices.

Beijing is injecting 9.2-trillion Yuan into its economy, with fresh bank loans and fiscal spending, and is reviving industrial and speculative demand for crude oil, copper, iron-ore, steel, and other raw materials. Coupled with the hallucinogenic QE drug that is injected daily by central banks in England, Japan, the Euro-zone, Switzerland and the United States, into global money markets, the "Commodity Super Cycle" is reviving, fueled by an influx of "hot-money" using crude oil and other commodities as a hedge against inflation and a weaker US Dollar.

With the central banks of England, the Eurozone, Japan, Switzerland and the US all engaging in a money printing orgy, traders are bidding-up the price of Gold Bullion and silver, and anything that can't be printed by central banks.

After stabilizing above $12 an ounce, the price of silver zoomed 25% higher in the month of May, moving in line with and even overtaking rising crude oil, copper, lumber, soybean and Gold Prices.

But silver's upward trajectory suddenly hit a roadblock at $16 an ounce, hit by a burst of selling on June 3rd, after "Bubbles" Bernanke surprised the market. Bernanke warned Congress that the Fed would stop printing money at some point in the future. "Either cuts in spending or increases in taxes will be necessary to stabilize the fiscal situation," Bernanke told the House Budget Committee. "The Fed won't monetize the debt," he warned.

Of course, the mukti-trillion-dollar question is whether Bernanke is simply bluffing, and will ultimately succumb to political pressure to keep the printing press rolling this year, or rather, would the T-bond vigilantes gain the upper hand, and push interest rates higher, in order to contain inflation pressure.

In a knee-jerk reaction to Bernanke's hawkish outburst, the yield on the Treasury's 2-year note, which is very sensitive to perceived shifts in Fed policy, shot-upwards by 50-basis points to as high as 1.42%. That put a temporary lid on the surging Gold Investment and silver markets.

"To the extent that yields are going up because the economic outlook is brighter, it would not be a good idea to oppose higher bond yields by boosting purchases of Treasuries," warned New York Fed chief and former Goldman Sachs economist William Dudley on June 5th.

Yet on the next business day, the Fed quickly reversed course and monetized $7.5 billion of five-year Treasuries. "We want to be sure that we'll be able to remove accommodation at an appropriate time and speed to insure that we don't have an inflation risk down the road," Bernanke said. "It's not going to be easy, we'll have to balance the risk on both sides, not going too soon and stunting the recovery and not going too late and having a bit of inflation," he said.

From all appearances so far, Bernanke and his entourage of money printers, are merely giving lip service to fighting inflation, in order to buy some extra time, while the hallucinogenic QE-drug becomes more deeply embedded in the markets. Dallas Fed chief Fisher said there was "no exact formula" for when to start withdrawing the tidal wave of cash it pumped into the economy. "We just want to make sure we don't repeat the mistakes made in the 1930's and mistakes made by the Japanese in the 1990's, by withdrawing cash too early," he said in a speech in Lubbock, Texas.

One of the other great mysteries in the financial markets is the behavior of the Australian Treasury bond market, which appears to be held hostage to the direction of US Treasury Notes, even though Australia's budget deficit and inflation outlook are in a much healthier state.

After hitting a historic low of 3.80% in late December, the yield on Australia's 10-year T-bond has rebounded by 200-basis points to as high as 5.80% last week, mirroring the 190-basis point rebound in US T-Note yields.

While inflationary pressures are flaring-up in the United States, the inflation outlook is sanguine in Australia. The Dow Jones Commodity Index is 31% lower than a year ago, thanks to a strong rebound by Aussie Dollar to above 80-US-cents. The Bank of Australia is taking full advantage of the virtuous chain of events, by pegging its overnight cash rate at a historic low of 3.00%.

Australia's budget deficit will be A$32-billion ($24.5-billion) in the year ending June 30th, before rising to A$57.6-billion in fiscal 2009-10 as a weak economy drives up unemployment and erodes tax receipts, Treasury chief Wayne Swan said. The budget deficit forecast for fiscal 2010 is equivalent to 5% of Australia's gross domestic product – far less than the US-budget shortfall at 13% of GDP.

Yet despite a more sound fiscal condition and a lower inflation outlook, Australia's bond yields are at the mercy of vigilantes operating in the US-debt markets.

GARY DORSCH is editor of the Global Money Trends newsletter. He worked as chief financial futures analyst for three clearing firms on the trading floor of the Chicago Mercantile Exchange before moving to the US and foreign equities trading desk of Charles Schwab and Co.

There he traded across 45 different exchanges, including Australia, Canada, Japan, Hong Kong, the Eurozone, London, Toronto, South Africa, Mexico and New Zealand. With extensive experience of forex, US high grade and corporate junk bonds, foreign government bonds, gold stocks, ADRs, a wide range of US equities and options as well as Canadian oil trusts, he wrote from 2000 to Sept. '05 a weekly newsletter, Foreign Currency Trends, for Charles Schwab's Global Investment department.

See the full archive of Gary Dorsch.


Please Note: All articles published here are to inform your thinking, not lead it. Only you can decide the best place for your money, and any decision you make will put your money at risk. Information or data included here may have already been overtaken by events – and must be verified elsewhere – should you choose to act on it. Please review our Terms & Conditions for accessing Gold News.

Follow Us

Facebook Youtube Twitter LinkedIn



Market Fundamentals